Goto Uni. Home Page logo.gif (3193 bytes) Goto main page

Laboratory 5 -
Operation of Batch Still with Methanol-Water Mixture

Supervisor: Dr. Jon Lee


Introduction

Batch Distillation is used widely within the chemical industry to purify small quantities of chemicals. A batch distillation column consists of a tank that is charged with the mixture to be separated and then heated to produce a vapour. The vapour leaves the pot and passes through the column where separation takes place. At the top of the column the vapour is condensed and part of the liquid produced (the reflux) flows down the column in counter current flow with the vapour rising up the column. The other part of the condensate is drawn off as the overhead product. In effect the batch distillation column is acting as the rectification section of a continuous distillation column.

Quite often the distillation column will be installed above a heated tank in which a reaction is taking place, so that separation can take place during the reaction process or after the reaction has been completed.

Objectives

The overall objective of this lab project is to study the separation of at water-methanol mixture in a pilot scale batch distillation column. The specific objectives are

  1. To determine the minimum reflux ratio for this separation
  2. To determine the maximum heating rate when the column is operating under total reflux.
  3. To compare the work required to separate the methanol from the water, with the minimum work for the separation.
  4. To investigate and explain the effect of reflux ratio on column operation.
  5. To measure the separating power of the column in terms of number of stages and the number of transfer units.

The first two objectives can and should be completed before the lab session.

 

 

Batch Distillation Experiment - Equipment Description

Description of the column

The batch distillation column consists of a round bottomed flask at the base, which is charged with a methanol - water mixture at the start of the experiment, a glass column packed with small glass cylinders, a condenser positioned above the column, a reflux valve, a product cooler and a collection cylinder (see the diagram on page 2).

Heaters

The round bottomed flask sits in an electric heater, which is controlled from the heater control panel. There are three heating elements and their power output is determined by the dials labelled VT1, VT2 and VT3. The dials should all be set to the same value, in which case the power output of the heaters (in Watts) is given by the equation

W = 0.15 S ^2.18 where S is the dial setting

The heaters are turned on and off using the switches next to the dials on the heater control panel. There are no temperature measuring instruments connected to the heater control so the dial will read zero.

Thermocouple Display

Thermocouples are used to measure the temperature at various points in the column. The thermocouples that are connected to the display have blue and white wires. They are numbered from 1-9. Numbers 1-6 measure temperatures in the column, with 6 being the temperature of the top product vapour. Numbers 7-9 measure the cooling water temperature at the inlet to the product cooler, the inlet to the condenser and the outlet of the condenser respectively. The dial is used to select which thermocouple outlet is displayed.

Reflux Valve Control

The reflux ratio is controlled using a solenoid valve which has two positions;

open - all the condensed liquid is returned to the column

closed - all the condensed liquid goes to the overhead product

The reflux ratio is determined by the ratio of the time the valve is open to the time the valve is closed. If the valve is open for twice as long as it is closed then the reflux ratio is 2. The dial on the reflux valve control box is used to set ratio of the time the valve is open to the time the valve is closed and therefore the numbers on the dial represent the actual reflux ratio. When the dial is at zero the valve will be open all the time. The switch on the control box turns the reflux valve on and off.

Sample Valves

There are 10 sample valves. Number 1 is a syringe which allows a sample to be taken from the round bottomed flask. Numbers 2 - 9 give samples of the liquid flow within the packing. Number 10 samples the overhead liquid product.

SAFETY NOTE: Samples coming from the column will be at temperatures of up to 100°C. Make sure that you hold the sample vial using tongs or heat resistant gloves. Do not hold the sample vial with you bear hands whilst taking a liquid sample from the column.

Batch Distillation Experiment - Experimental Procedure

  1. At 1 p.m. on the day of the experiment go into the pilot plant lab and make sure that the batch distillation column has been started up. If the column has not been started up go and see Rob Dixon the lab technician (he is normally in the Chemical Engineering Lab on the 3rd floor). Do not attempt to start up the column unless you have talked to Rob Dixon or Dr. Jon Lee.
  2. At 2 p.m. when you come to do the experiment, you should find the column warmed up and operating under total reflux.
  3. Measure the temperatures at all points within the column, and take liquid samples from the round bottomed flask and sample valves 3, 6, 9 and 10.
  4. Set the reflux ratio to its first value (you choose).
  5. Measure the temperature profile in the column every 15 minutes.
  6. Take a liquid sample of the top product (valve 10) every 10 minutes.
  7. Take liquid samples from the round bottomed flask and valves 3,6 and 9 after 30 minutes and after 60 minutes.
  8. After one hour the column should have reached steady state. In the last five minutes of the hour, measure the flow rate of the distillate product stream, the flow rate of the cooling water and the temperature of the cooling water as the inlet and outlet of the condenser.
  9. Change the reflux ratio to a new value (you choose) and repeat steps 4 - 8.
  10. When you have got the data for two values of the reflux ratio, shut down the column as described on page 5.

Methanol Concentration Measurement

After you have taken a liquid sample make sure you screw a lid onto the sample vial immediately or else you will loose some of the liquid sample as vapour and change its composition.

After the sample has cooled down to room temperature measure its refractive index using the refractometer set up in the Chemical Engineering Lab on the 3rd floor.

Using the attached calibration curve convert these refractive index readings into mass fractions of methanol.

Batch Distillation Experiment - Start Up and Shut Down

Procedure for starting up the batch distillation column

  1. Make sure that the round bottomed flask is filled so that the liquid surface inside the flask is level with the top of the heater outside the flask. The composition of the liquid within the flask should be 10% methanol and 90% water.
  2. Make sure that the inlet where the water-methanol solution is poured into the to the round bottomed flask, is blocked using a glass stopper.
  3. Turn on the cooling water supply to the condenser and product cooler.
  4. Make sure the product collection cylinder is in place.
  5. Set the dials on the heater control panel (VT1, VT2 and VT3) to 70.
  6. Turn on the mains supply to heater control unit.
  7. Turn on the heaters using the switches next to each dial.
  8. Switch on the thermocouple display and the reflux valve control unit.
  9. Make sure the dial on the reflux valve control is set to zero, so that the column is operating at total reflux.
  10. Leave the column to warm up for 1-2 hours.

Procedure for shutting down the batch distillation column

  1. Set the dial on the reflux valve control unit to zero, so that the column is operating under total reflux.
  2. Switch off the power to the reflux valve control unit and the thermocouple display.
  3. Set the dials on all the heaters to zero and turn off the power to the heaters using the switches next to the dials.
  4. Turn off the mains supply to the heater control unit.
  5. Let the column cool down for 2 hours.
  6. Turn off the cooling water supply to the condenser and the product cooler.

Batch Distillation Experiment - Treatment of Results

You should produce plots of column position against temperature and column position against methanol concentration as a function of time, for each reflux ratio used. Sketch graphs are shown below.

Use the measured cooling water flow rate, cooling water inlet and outlet temperatures to the condenser, the power supplied by the heater and the flowrate of the distillate to work out the energy used per kilogramme of product, to effect the separation of methanol and water. Compare this to the minimum energy required for the separation (Reference 3) and suggest reasons for the difference in values.

If the top product composition has maintained an approximately constant value (see Reference 2) then use a McCabe-Thiele plot to measure the number of stages and the number of transfer units. The equilibrium data for the methanol water system can be calculated using the data given at the end of this sheet or experimental data can be used (see Reference 1).

You should also check to see if the liquid concentration samples taken at the end of one hour lie on the operating line on the McCabe Thiele plot, used to calculate the number of stages.

 

Calibration Curve for the Refractometer

 

Data

 

References

  1. Gmehling J., Onken U., "Vapour Liquid Equilibrium Data Series", 2nd Edition, 1991, DECHEMA, Frankfurt, Vol 1, part 1, pages 37 - 76.
  2. McCabe W.L., "Unit Operations of Chemical Engineering", 5th Edition, 1993, McGraw Hill, Chapter 18, pages 576-580.
  3. Pratt H.R.C., "Countercurrent Separation Processes", 1st Edition, 1967, Elsevier, Amsterdam, Chapter 1, pages 16-22.